Reducing consistency in human realism increases the uncanny valley effect; increasing category uncertainty does not

• DOI: 10.1016/j.cognition.2015.09.019
• Publication Date: 2015-10-01T22:45:53Z
• Authors: Karl F. MacDorman; Debaleena Chattop...
• Keywords: Adult; Male; computer animation; Linguistics and Language; Face perception; Computer animation; Cognitive Neuroscience; anthropomorphism; 05 social sciences; Uncertainty; Experimental and Cognitive Psychology; Anthropomorphism; Young Adult; Social Perception; face perception; Humans; Photorealism; Female; 0501 psychology and cognitive sciences; Facial Recognition

Human replicas may elicit unintended cold, eerie feelings in viewers, an effect known as the uncanny valley. Masahiro Mori, who proposed the effect in 1970, attributed it to inconsistencies in the replica's realism with some of its features perceived as human and others as nonhuman. This study aims to determine whether reducing realism consistency in visual features increases the uncanny valley effect. In three rounds of experiments, 548 participants categorized and rated humans, animals, and objects that varied from computer animated to real. Two sets of features were manipulated to reduce realism consistency. (For humans, the sets were eyes-eyelashes-mouth and skin-nose-eyebrows.) Reducing realism consistency caused humans and animals, but not objects, to appear eerier and colder. However, the predictions of a competing theory, proposed by Ernst Jentsch in 1906, were not supported: The most ambiguous representations-those eliciting the greatest category uncertainty-were neither the eeriest nor the coldest.