Ideology and the Market Metaphor in Rational Choice Theory of Religion: A Rhetorical Critique of ‘Religious Economies’

• DOI: 10.1177/0896920511415431
• Publication Date: 2012-05-03T02:31:34Z
• Authors: Andrew M. McKinnon
• Keywords: 330; rhetoric; neo-liberalism; rational choice theory; ideology; HM Sociology; 06 humanities and the arts; Rodney Stark; HM; 0603 philosophy, ethics and religion; metaphor; sociology of religion

Despite the many criticisms of the empirical and theoretical adequacy of Rational Choice theory, it continues to have considerable influence and appeal in the sociological study of religion. This article examines the use of the market metaphor and its subsidiary metaphors, with a view to understanding how these metaphors work in rational choice theory, and what this might be able to tell us about its enduring influence. I suggest that the metaphor is a useful one for studying religion in a capitalist, commodity oriented society, but when we forget that the ‘religious economy’ is a metaphor, it comes to serve ideological purposes well suited to the neo-liberal agenda. The market (conceived after a neo-conservative fashion) is thereby naturalized and serves to reinforce the ideology of a one-dimensional society.