Association of hospital volume with conversion to open from minimally invasive colectomy in patients with diverticulitis: A national analysis

• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0284729
• Publication Date: 2023-04-28T17:26:42Z
• Authors: Shayan Ebrahimian; Arjun Verma; Sara Sakowitz; Manuel Orellana O...; Nikhil Chervu; Aimal Khan; Alexander Hawkins; Peyman Benharash; Hanjoo Lee
• Keywords: Adult; Diverticular Diseases; General Science & Technology; Science; Q; R; Hospitals; 3. Good health; Postoperative Complications; Treatment Outcome; Clinical Research; Health Sciences; 617; Medicine; Humans; Minimally Invasive Surgical Procedures; Laparoscopy; Public Health; Patient Safety; Diverticulitis; Colectomy; Research Article; Retrospective Studies

Background Despite the known advantages of minimally invasive surgery (MIS) for diverticular disease, the impact of conversions to open (CtO) colectomy remains understudied. The present study used a nationally representative database to characterize risk factors and outcomes associated with CtO in patients with diverticular disease.

Methods All elective adult hospitalizations entailing colectomy for diverticulitis were identified in the 2017–2019 Nationwide Readmissions Database. Annual institutional caseloads of MIS and open colectomy were independently tabulated. Restricted cubic splines were utilized to non-linearly estimate the risk-adjusted association between hospital volumes and CtO. Additional regression models were developed to evaluate the association of CtO with outcomes of interest.

Results Of an estimated 110,281 patients with diverticulitis who met study criteria, 39.3% underwent planned open colectomy, 53.3% completed MIS, and 7.4% had a CtO. Following adjustment, an inverse relationship between hospital MIS volume and risk of CtO was observed. In contrast, increasing hospital open volume was positively associated with greater risk of CtO. On multivariable analysis, CtO was associated with lower odds of mortality (AOR 0.3, p = 0.001) when compared to open approach, and similar risk of mortality when compared to completed MIS (AOR 0.7, p = 0.436).

Conclusion In the present study, institutional MIS volume exhibited inverse correlation with adjusted rates of CtO, independent of open colectomy volume. CtO was associated with decreased rates of mortality compared to planned open approach but equivalence risk relative to completed MIS. Our findings highlight the importance of MIS experience and suggest that MIS may be safely pursued as the initial surgical approach among diverticulitis patients.