Significance of time awake for predicting pilots' fatigue on short‐haul flights: implications for flight duty time regulations

• DOI: 10.1111/jsr.12186
• Publication Date: 2014-07-21T04:31:13Z
• Authors: Martin Vejvoda; Eva‐Maria Elmenhorst; Sibylle Pennig; Gernot Plath; Hartmut Maass; Kristjof Tritschler; Mathias Basner; Daniel Aeschbach
• Keywords: Adult; Male; Time Factors; Aircraft; hazard; late finishes; Workload; sleepiness; early starts; Young Adult; 03 medical and health sciences; 0302 clinical medicine; Work Schedule Tolerance; Humans; Attention; Wakefulness; Fatigue; cockpit crew; Middle Aged; Actigraphy; duty duration; Air Travel; Sleep Deprivation; Sleep

SummaryEuropean regulations restrict the duration of the maximum daily flight duty period for pilots as a function of the duty start time and the number of scheduled flights. However, late duty end times that may include long times awake are not specifically regulated. In this study, fatigue levels in pilots finishing their duty late at night (00:00–01:59 hour) were analysed and compared with pilots starting their duty early (05:00–06:59 hour). Fatigue levels of 40 commercial short‐haul pilots were studied during a total of 188 flight duty periods, of which 87 started early and 22 finished late. Pilots used a small handheld computer to maintain a duty and sleep log, and to indicate fatigue levels immediately after each flight. Sleep logs were checked with actigraphy. Pilots on late‐finishing flight duty periods were more fatigued at the end of their duty than pilots on early‐starting flight duty periods, despite the fact that preceding sleep duration was longer by 1.1 h. Linear mixed‐model regression identified time awake as a preeminent factor predicting fatigue. Workload had a minor effect. Pilots on late‐finishing flight duty periods were awake longer by an average of 5.5 h (6.6 versus 1.1 h) before commencing their duty than pilots who started early in the morning. Late‐finishing flights were associated with long times awake at a time when the circadian system stops promoting alertness, and an increased, previously underestimated fatigue risk. Based on these findings, flight duty limitations should consider not only duty start time, but also the time of the final landing.