Recruitment and retention of participants from socioeconomically deprived communities: lessons from the Awareness and Beliefs About Cancer (ABACus3) Randomised Controlled Trial

• DOI: 10.1186/s12874-020-01149-x
• Publication Date: 2020-11-04T09:08:39Z
• Authors: Vasiliki Kolovou; Yvonne Moriarty; Stephanie Gilbert; Harriet Quinn-Sco...; Julia Townson; Louise Padgett; Sioned Owen; Peter Buckle; Adrian Edwards; Julie Hepburn; Mandy Lau; Maura Matthews; Caroline Mitchell; Richard Neal; Rebecca Playle; Mike Robling; Stephanie Smits; Rob Trubey; Fiona Wood; Kate Brain
• Keywords: Adult; Health intervention; Medicine (General); Randomised control trial; Community settings; Middle Aged; 16. Peace & justice; 3. Good health; Socioeconomic deprivation; 03 medical and health sciences; R5-920; 0302 clinical medicine; Retention; Neoplasms; Humans; Female; Recruitment; Research Article

Abstract

Background Recruitment of research participants poses challenges in socioeconomically deprived areas. The Awareness and Beliefs About Cancer (ABACus) phase 3 Randomised Control Trial recruited adult participants from socioeconomically deprived areas using a combined healthcare/community engagement model. We report the strategies used to successfully recruit and retain our trial participant sample.

Methods Community and healthcare settings in areas of high socioeconomic deprivation were identified by lay advisors who recruited participants opportunistically or by appointment. Follow-up was done by telephone or post at 2-weeks and 6-months after recruitment, and all participants were offered financial incentives. Qualitative interviews were conducted with lay advisors regarding their experience and reflections.

Results The lay advisors identified and contacted 107 potential recruitment venues across South and West Yorkshire and South East Wales of which 41.1% (n = 42) were opened for recruitment. A total of 234 participants were recruited, with 91% (n = 212) retention at 2-weeks and 85% (n = 199) at 6-months. Community settings yielded 75% (n = 176) of participants. Participants had a mean age of 61.3 years and 63.3% (n = 148) were female, with 66% (n = 154) resident in the most deprived geographical areas. Lay advisors described recruitment as intensive, although engaging participants was easier in community settings.

Conclusions The ABACus3 trial achieved recruitment and high retention with a population that is often “hard to reach” or entirely missed in health research. Strategies were specifically tailored to engage the venues and adult residents of highly deprived areas. Future studies recruiting adults living in the most deprived areas might benefit from community recruitment and from collaborating with local gatekeepers who are key to engagement. This study adheres to CONSORT guidelines.

Trial registration Retrospectively registered with ISRCTN (http://www.isrctn.com/ISRCTN16872545) on 12.01.2018.