The role of validation in optimization models for forest management

• DOI: 10.1186/s13595-024-01235-w
• Publication Date: 2024-05-08T07:01:48Z
• Authors: Jitka Janová; Kai Bödeker; Logan Bingham; Mengistie Kindu; Thomas Knoke
• Keywords: Review Paper ; Ecological modelling ; Decision support system ; Verification ; Model credibility ; Sensitivity analysis ; Environmental management; Environmental management; Verification; Forestry; 04 agricultural and veterinary sciences; SD1-669.5; ddc:; Model credibility; ddc:630; 0401 agriculture, forestry, and fisheries; Sensitivity analysis; Decision support system; Ecological modelling

Abstract Key message A validation convention can be established for forest management optimization models. It consists of (1) the delivery face validation, (2) performing at least one other technique, and (3) an explicit discussion how model fulfills stated purpose. Validation by potential users or external experts is high importance. Context Optimization modeling has long assisted ecosystems, but credibility these models always been debated with criticisms concerning data quality, failures to include relevant processes in scope models, inclusion unrealistic assumptions. widely considered crucial establishing general, validate particular represents a permanent question generally operations research. Aims We aim synthesize practical recommendations development frameworks management. Methods selected sample 46 studies devoted applied practice, analysed contents respect provided critical review. Results clarified meaning usage different validation-related terms that are commonly encountered literature, identified categorised various methods used demonstrate credibility, derived organizing principles helped suggest improvements frameworks. Conclusions we consist three stages. By providing structured consistent information about processes, researchers better their work readers users.