Early Warning Signals of Social Transformation: A Case Study from the US Southwest

• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0163685
• Publication Date: 2016-10-05T18:54:02Z
• Authors: Katherine A. Spie...; Matthew A. Peeples; Donna M. Glowacki; Andrew Dugmore
• Keywords: Science; Q; R; 06 humanities and the arts; Models, Theoretical; 15. Life on land; 300; United States; Archaeology; Social Class; 13. Climate action; Medicine; Humans; 0601 history and archaeology; Ecosystem; Research Article

Recent research in ecology suggests that generic indicators, referred to as early warning signals (EWS), may occur before significant transformations, both critical and non-critical, in complex systems. Up to this point, research on EWS has largely focused on simple models and controlled experiments in ecology and climate science. When humans are considered in these arenas they are invariably seen as external sources of disturbance or management. In this article we explore ways to include societal components of socio-ecological systems directly in EWS analysis. Given the growing archaeological literature on 'collapses,' or transformations, in social systems, we investigate whether any early warning signals are apparent in the archaeological records of the build-up to two contemporaneous cases of social transformation in the prehistoric US Southwest, Mesa Verde and Zuni. The social transformations in these two cases differ in scope and severity, thus allowing us to explore the contexts under which warning signals may (or may not) emerge. In both cases our results show increasing variance in settlement size before the transformation, but increasing variance in social institutions only before the critical transformation in Mesa Verde. In the Zuni case, social institutions appear to have managed the process of significant social change. We conclude that variance is of broad relevance in anticipating social change, and the capacity of social institutions to mitigate transformation is critical to consider in EWS research on socio-ecological systems.