One Size Does Not Fit All: An Individualized Approach to Understand Heterogeneous Cognitive Performance in Autistic Adults

• DOI: 10.31234/osf.io/dmbfp
• Publication Date: 2022-08-04T10:41:37Z
• Authors: Carolien Torenvliet; Annabeth Groenman; Tulsi Radhoe; Joost Agelink van...; Hilde Geurts
• Keywords: Adult; Autism Spectrum Disorder; 150; Cognitive Psychology; 610; Social and Behavioral Sciences; Clinical Psychology; 03 medical and health sciences; Cognition; Memory, Short-Term; 0302 clinical medicine; Neurodevelopmental Disorders; Humans; Cognitive Dysfunction; Quantitative Methods; Statistical Methods; Autistic Disorder; Clinical Neuropsychology

Cognitive performances of autistic people vary widely. Therefore, previous group-based comparisons on cognitive aging in autistic adults might have overlooked those autistic adults that are particularly vulnerable for cognitive decline. Multivariate normative comparisons (MNC) statistically assess individual cognitive differences on the entire cognitive profile. Cognitive deviancy as indicated by MNC accurately predicts future cognitive decline, and is therefore sensitive in detecting meaningful cognitive differences. The current study aimed to 1) assess the applicability of MNC to assess cognitive performance in autism individually, and 2) understand heterogeneous cognitive performance in autistic adults. As pre-registered, we performed MNC in a sample of 254 non-autistic adults, and two independent samples of respectively 118, and 86 autistic adults (20-85 years, mean: 50 years). Cognitive performance was measured on eleven outcomes in six domains (verbal/visual memory, working memory, verbal fluency, Theory of Mind, and psychomotor speed). Using MNC, about twice as many autistic individuals had a deviant cognitive profile (i.e., deviated statistically from the multivariate normspace) as compared to non-autistic individuals. Importantly, most autistic individuals (>80%) did not have a deviant cognitive profile. Having a deviant profile was significantly associated with higher levels of psychological distress in autistic adults specifically, showing the clinical relevance of this method. Therefore, MNC seem a useful tool to individually detect meaningful cognitive differences in autism. These results are consistent with previous cognitive studies suggesting that most autistic adults show fairly similar cognitive profiles to non-autistic adults, yet highlight the necessity for approaches reflecting the heterogeneity observed in autistic people.